Where to Find Outrageous Milkshakes on Long Island 🥤
Looking to overindulge in an outrageous milkshake this weekend? We've got you covered! Long Island is home to plenty of spots serving up over-the-top milkshakes to cure that sweet tooth. Check out our top picks below.
Burgerology
Although known for its delicious burgers, Burgerology is also providing its customers with some of the best milkshakes around. These milkshakes are created with high-quality ingredients and are unlike any you have tried before. Their menu features some unique milkshake options such as the Ferrero Rocher, which is vanilla ice cream spun together with Nutella and vanilla sugar wafers, topped with a four-layer cake, Ferrero Rocher chocolate, and a chocolate tub. Some of their other milkshakes include the Cookie Doughnut and the Crazy Monkey. Don’t miss out on these crazy shakes as Burgerology has four locations on Long Island in Rockville Centre, Huntington, Patchogue, and Stony Brook.
Babylon Burger Bar
The Babylon Burger Bar is another spot with not only tasty burgers but amazing hand-spun milkshakes as well. This restaurant is providing a destination for guests to experience unique and creative burgers and shakes. Their Super Duper Milkshake list has some pretty crazy options including the Sweet And Salty. This is a hand-spun vanilla milkshake with the caramel coating and chocolate frosting inside the glass, M&Ms and Reeses on the outside, topped with a chocolate-covered-pretzel, pretzel rods, a snickers candy bar, whipped cream, and chocolate syrup. The Babylon Burger bar also has an Oreo Cookies N’ Cream shake that is topped with an ice cream sandwich and a Red Velvet Kiss, which is topped with a whole piece of red velvet cake! With outrageous toppings and flavors, this spot is a must-try for your next milkshake craving! Stop on Monday & Tuesday from 4 p.m. to 9 p.m., Wednesday, Thursday, & Sunday from 12 p.m. to 9 p.m., or Friday & Saturday from 12 p.m. to 10 p.m. View some of their crazy creations on Facebook or Instagram.
Diner by the Sea
A spot known for its incredible old-fashioned milkshakes is Diner by the Sea. This laid-back diner is whipping up classic diner dishes and creative milkshakes for all of Long Beach to enjoy. People have been coming from all over the island to try out their thick, creamy, and colorful milkshakes. Their menu features milkshake flavors such as Fruity Pebbles, Banananilla Wafer, Cinnabon, Coco Pebbles, and plenty more! A real show stopper for many guests is the Nespresso Nutella Milkshake. All their milkshakes are topped off with colorful syrup and fun straws. Make sure to visit Diner by the Sea and try out all their amazing milkshakes! This diner is open every day from 9 a.m. to 6 p.m. Follow their Instagram to learn more.
Prime Burger Bar
When visiting Prime Burger Bar, it is a must that you save room for their amazing hand-spun shakes! Each milkshake is blended together perfectly and finished off by hand, with only the best ingredients. Their Super Shakes start off as any ordinary shake but are then topped off with an entire dessert from cookies, to full pieces of cake, to cotton candy. These shakes are over-the-top and definitely picture-worthy! Some of their milkshake options include the Birthday Cake Milkshake, Cotton Candy, and Ultimate Fudge Brownie. If looking for something different, Prime Burger Bar also provides the option to customize a milkshake to your liking. Stop on Monday & Tuesday from 4 p.m. to 9 p.m., Wednesday, Thursday, & Sunday from 12 p.m. to 9 p.m., or Friday & Saturday from 12 p.m. to 10 p.m. Follow them on Facebook today.
Manny's Sweet Treats
This dessert shop is serving up some pretty outrageous milkshakes in an old-fashioned orange & white parlor. Manny’s mission is to create a one-of-a-kind dessert experience, and their crazy milkshakes do just that! Their Insane Milkshake Menu features options such as the Guilty Pleasure, which is a chocolate milkshake with brownies, pop tarts, churros, marshmallows, and whipped cream. Some other shakes are the Royal Milkshake and the Queen Insane Milkshake. Come try out these crazy milkshakes today at Manny’s Sweet Treats in Mineola. This spot is open Tuesday through Thursday & Sunday from 12 p.m. to 11 p.m., and Friday & Saturday from 12 p.m. to 12 a.m. Follow them on Facebook and Instagram to see some of their amazing desserts.
Comment your favorites below! Did we miss any? Let us know!
